Review of Les Misérables
Back again! I was originally supposed to see Les Mis with some friends on
Tuesday while home for the 4th of July weekend, but I ended up not being able to
go. So, to make up for it, I made a trip out this afternoon.
Today's cast: Rest of cast in order of
appearance: * James Chip Leonard understudied for Thénardier
I was hoping to catch Norman Large as Thénardier since David Benoit had his last
show on Tuesday, but James Chip Leonard has gone on for the last couple shows
and did again this afternoon (so I guess I'll have to wait until next time).
This was, however, my first time catching Joan Almedilla since Tonya Dixon left
and Ashley Fox Linton was on in Leslie Henstock's place today as well, so it was
interesting to see some new people in different roles. Randal was out few shows this week -- two evenings because of laryngitis
(apparently, some bug is going around the cast) and Saturday matinee because of
the rotation schedule. He sounded great, but there were a few times here and
there where I could tell his voice wasn't back to 100%. Some words came across
as a little rough and he cut short a note somewhere (I think it was "if I stay
silent, I am damned" in "Who am I?"). His voice also wavered the
slightest bit on his long note at the very end of "What Have I Done? (Valjean's
Soliloquy)". Other than that, though, he was outstanding -- as usual. It seemed like the second half of "Bring Him Home"
was even more pleading than usual, and there was not even a hint of him
struggling with his voice in that scene. It was so amazing that he brought the house down at
the end and got an extra long applause that had a second round of cheers before
it died down. Just awesome. Because I'd seen three different actors go on as Javert in the previous three
performances I saw, this was going to be the second time for one of them, and I
was glad that it was Robert Hunt. I enjoyed his performance last time and did so
even more this time. He doesn't have the booming voice that Trent Blanton does,
but he does have the capability to convey so much intensity in his acting that
"Stars" and "Javert's Suicide" were once again his highlighting moments. I also
like his cat-like prowling movements in "The Confrontation" as he is trying to
corner Valjean from the other side of Fantine's bed, as if there was absolutely
no way he was going to let Valjean escape if he could do anything about it. He even seemed vicious at times, particularly towards the end of their exchange.
There's just something about his facial expressions though -- sometimes he
contorts his face in a way that looks like he's about to break out laughing when
he's trying to be angry or something.
At the very beginning, Joan's Fantine is quite clean in terms of her singing and
her voice is nice to listen to in "At the End of the Day". "I Dreamed a
Dream" similarly started out beautifully and she really does have a great voice for the
mid-range notes and when she's supposed to sing softly. However, she isn't quite
as aggressive in that scene as I'm used to (i.e. grabbing back the letter from
Factory Girl and when she's defending herself about Cosette), but she was quite
aggressive when fighting with Bamatabois and made this feral growling sound with
the "r" in "rat". Her acting was quite good. For example, I
got the sense that she was dejected and that life had given her a hard slap in the
face in "I Dreamed a Dream". Her desperation in
"Come to Me" came across quite well, particularly when she was hallucinating,
and she actually died quite convincingly. Unfortunately, Joan doesn't quite have the power to
belt out some of the notes in "I Dreamed a Dream" and in a couple places in
subsequent songs. It is just a matter of where she is letting her voice
resonate, I think, and she just isn't able to project her voice to fill the
theatre like other Fantines I've seen/heard. As a result, her voice sometimes sounds muted or dampened.
(It's too bad I don't remember her
performance when Les Mis was in San Francisco in 2000 to compare.) She
also didn't address either Valjean or Javert in "Fantine's Arrest" when she
sings "I never did no wrong / my daughter's close to dying / if there's God
above, he'd let me die instead" -- it was very vague, but it still worked well.
So adorable, as always. I just love the way she is able to let Young Cosette's strong
spirit come through. In the past times I've seen Rachel, she does the second
half of the song kneeling and with her hands on her knees. But this time, she
placed her hands on the floor in front of her such that she was leaning forward
a bit more, and it makes such a difference in the way Young Cosette's dream of a
better place and life comes across. She is such a delight to watch. This may be the first time I've seen an understudy for Thénardier, but if I'd
come into this performance not knowing James Chip Leonard was an understudy, I
would never have known. He has a great singing voice that makes his songs
musically wonderful. He's not quite as wild as David Benoit, but James is still
a great Thénardier. He comes across as very calculating and doing what he thinks
will get him what he wants. It was also quite hilarious the way he made this
cat-hissing sound at the male dancer he points out as "queer" (I still can't
place a name to his face) in "Beggars at the Feast". Somehow, Jennifer scares me more and more every time I see her. Part of it is
the freaky-looking prosthetics she wears on her face, but a lot of it is just
the expressions she has on her face at various times during her performance. She
was absolutely hilarious, though, in her part of "Master of the House" and it all has to
do with the way her lines are delivered. She got a lot of laughs there. Like last time, he was adorable. And he was able to toss the bullet bag to
Enjolras this time! He also did an excellent job when delivering the news about
Lamarque -- he took an extra long pause to prelude the gravity of his
announcement. But I did notice that he was rather focused on gathering the
bullets and rolling up the bag (both this time and last time) such that his
singing in "Gavroche's Death" wasn't delivered as naturally as it could have
been. And he still is kind of reaching out to get his body to land on the
stuffed dummy when he is shot for the final time, rather than collapsing (which
Noah E. Galvin does really well).
Melissa was apparently also out earlier in the week due to laryngitis and there
was perhaps the slightest remnant of the bug in her voice. But I amazed how she is capable of giving Eponine such a wide range of emotions, ranging from
bouncy flirtatiousness to anger to this kind of self-pity that borders on being
whiney (though, in a way that fits Eponine's character). Her interaction with Adam's Marius was a
bit more natural this time (whereas, before, it seemed like the way they'd poke
each other on the arm was a tad
repetitive), particularly in Eponine's very first scene when she takes Marius'
books where she looks like a girl messing with her first crush (which is
probably true for Eponine). She even pretended to tickle Adam in "Eponine's
Errand" when Marius asks her to find Cosette -- that was cute. I am still blown
away by her "On My Own". I want to cry every time I hear her voice echo through
the theatre's silence at the end of "a world that's full of happiness that I
have never known". Wow.
After seeing Adam five times now, I am starting to notice itty-bitty little
things that don't strike me as quite right. One has to do with the way his vowels
come across, although it's not really entirely his fault. American English has
some vowels that just don't resonate well, as opposed to British English. There
is kind of a continuum in the way vowels can be shaped, and it seems as if Adam
shapes his on the extreme end of American English and made them a bit nasally.
It's just a little strange. He also wasn't quite as
dynamic with using his voice as last week, but "Empty Chairs at Empty Tables"
was still very moving. I also noticed that this time he looked at Melissa and
actually acknowledged her presence just before "One Day More", whereas he
usually doesn't even seem to know she's there offering to be a friend to him.
I love Ashley's voice! She has such a nice soprano voice that even her
upper-range notes are so beautiful to listen to, and that they're not a struggle
to project and to let resonate in the right space (which is something I feel
Leslie struggles with). There were just a couple of places that sounded like she
wasn't quite 100% in control of her voice, but it was just when going up to high
notes or coming down from them, and it was hardly noticeable unless you were
listening really carefully. Perhaps she isn't quite as youthful and bubbly as
Leslie, but she certainly is not exactly meek either. Ashley's Cosette is
slightly more mature, but she plays off of Adam Jacob's Marius really well and
their voices blend very nicely as well. "A Heart Full of Love" was just
gorgeous, as was "Every Day" (although she wasn't as tender with Marius as
Leslie was last time).
Each subsequent show that I watch, I become a little more attentive to the
little nuances that Michael puts into his Enjolras. I paid more attention to the
dynamic between him and Grantaire, particularly in "Drink With Me" (where
Michael's Enjolras looked bothered and a bit angry that Grantaire might actually
be right in that they might be fighting and giving their lives for nothing, and
then later reaffirm their camaraderie with Grantaire holding out his bottle and
Enjolras holding out his rifle). I
noticed this last time also, but when Enjolras sends the women and fathers of
children from the barricade, Michael does it with such a sense of urgency that
it was a little surprising, like they had to leave very quickly (but I guess
that makes sense given their circumstances).
Miscellaneous notes:
Overall rating: 4 out of 5 -- it didn't have nearly the energy it did last week,
but at the same time, I wasn't expecting it to. Part of it may just be that
people are getting over various bugs still.
Sunday, July 3, 2005 at 2:00pm
Curran Theatre
San Francisco, CA
Jean Valjean
Randal Keith
Mme. Thénardier
Jennifer Butt
Javert
Robert Hunt
Gavroche
Sean Gilbert
Fantine
Joan Almedilla
Eponine
Melissa Lyons
Young Cosette
Rachel Schier
Enjolras
Michael Halling
Young Eponine
Meg Guzulescu
Marius
Adam Jacobs
M. Thénardier
James Chip Leonard *
Cosette
Ashley Fox Linton **
Farmer
Roger Seyer
Montparnasse
Kip Driver
The Bishop of Digne
Michael St. John
Babet
Kevin David Thomas
Constables
Don Brewer ***, Kevin David Thomas
Brujon
David Michael Felty
Foreman
Pierce Peter Brandt
Claquesous
Don Brewer ***
Factory Girl
Kelly McCormick
Combeferre
Pierce Peter Brandt
Old Woman (locket)
Karen Elliot
Feuilly
Eric Briarley
Crone (hair)
Nina Negri
Courfeyrac
Roger Seyer
Pimp
Don Brewer ***
Joly
Charles Hagerty
Bamatabois
Trent Blanton
Grantaire
Trent Blanton
Fauchelevant
Don Brewer ***
Lesgles
Michael St. John
Old Beggar Woman ("Look Down")
Marnie Nicolella
Jean Prouvaire
Ryan Williams
Young Prostitute
Carrie A. Johnson
Major Domo
Charles Hagerty
** Ashley Fox Linton understudied for Leslie Henstock
*** Don Brewer replaces roles usually played by James Chip Leonard
**** Lisa Morris replaces roles usually played by Ashley Fox Linton